1/26/50 Norfolk, Va., Ledger-Dispatch? or Virginian-Pilot?:
PITCHING HORSESHOES By Billy Rose
THE RIDDLE OF PATIENCE WORTH
Next time you meet a fellow who doesn't believe in anything
he can't measure with a slide rule, ask him to give you a
logical explanation of documented case history of Patience
Worth...
On a July evening in 1913, two St. Louis housewives, a
Mrs. John Curran and a Mrs. Emily Hutchings, were amusing
themselves with an ouija board - a parlor pastime as popular
then as canasta is now. Suddenly Mrs. Curran felt a strong
pressure on her hands and the pointer began to spell out a
message: "Many moons ago I lived. Again I come. Patience
Worth my name."
When the skeptical housewife asked to know more about the
lady at the other end of the line, the board immediately
answered that Patience Worth had been born in Dorsetshire,
England, in 1694, and had always wanted to be a writer.
SO BEGAN the strangest literary collaboration in the history
of psychic phenomena, and during the next 15 years, with
Mrs. Curran acting as medium, Patience Worth turned out four
full-length novels and almost 2,500 poems - 3,000,000 words
in all.
The first novel, "A Sorry Tale," was published by the
reputable and unsensationally-minded firm of Henry Holt and
Company, and when the New York Times reviewed it on July 8,
1917, it said, "This long and intricate tale of Jewish and
Roman life during the time of Christ is constructed with the
precision and accuracy of a master hand. It is a wonderful,
a beautiful and noble book."
The second novel, "Hope Trueblood," was the story of a
peasant girl in 17th Century England, and it was extolled by
a London reviewer as "a landmark of fiction." ... and in
"Braithwaite's Anthology of Poetry for 1917," there were
three poems by Vachel Lindsay, three by Amy Lowell, one by
Edgar Lee Masters, and five by Patience Worth.
The easy explanation for this phenomenon, of course, is that
the St. Louis housewife was a talented writer who had
invented the story of Patience Worth to get herself a little
publicity. But before you make up your mind, consider the
following.
AT THE BEGINNING, Mrs. Curran got her messages via the ouija
board a letter at a time, but halfway through the first
book, she began to "see" whole words and sentences, and from
then on she dictated to her husband at the rate of 110 words
per minute...and hardly a dozen of the 3,000,000 words were
of a vintage later than the 17th Century.
A great deal of her writing was done in the presence of
reliable witnesses and investigators, and etymologists who
examined her prose and poetry testified that it was
impossible, without years of study and training, for a person
to compose as much as a short story in 17th Century English.
Moreover, they unanimously agreed that the middle-class
housewife who had never gone to high school and never been
out of Missouri was the last person in St. Louis to write a
70,000-word narrative in iambic blank verse in 70 hours.
MANY OTHER oddish facts about this medium confused the
psychologists and non-believers who came to investigate.
Mrs. Curran often worked on three or four stories
simultaneously, and would skip from one to the other in the
course of a sitting without losing track of the narratives...
and once, when her husband mislaid an early chapter of "A
Sorry Tale," Patience Worth obligingly dictated it all over
again.
In St. Louis in 1920, before an audience of writers
scientists and civic leaders at the Artists' Guild, Patience
Worth was asked through Mrs. Curran to make up a 25-line
poem, each line beginning with a different letter of the
alphabet - which she did without faltering, going from "a"
to "z" and leaving out the letter "x" as per instruction.
WHO WAS PATIENCE WORTH? Well, various researchers went into
this carefully and reported that a girl by that name was
born in 1694 in Dorsetshire County, England; that some 30
years later she migrated to America, and was killed during
an Indian attack in King Phillip's War...and that many of the
architectural landmarks referred to in her novels are still
standing in Dorsetshire, and local records indicated that
others had existed around 1694.
Patience Worth stopped communicating with Mrs. Curran in
1928, and Mrs. Curran died nine years later, but to this day
nobody has been able to successfully ridicule this
greatest-of-all literary riddles. Many psychologists agree
with Dr. Walter Franklin Prince of the Boston Society for
Psychic Research who, after spending considerable time on the
case, said, "Either our concept of what we call the
subconscious must be radically altered so as to include
potencies of which we hitherto have had no knowledge, or else
some cause operating through, but not originating in, the
subconscious of Mrs. Curran must be acknowledged."
6/06/66 [...]'s ltr. to Librarian:
Librarian, A.R.E.:
Thanks for sending "'Patience Worth' - a psychic mystery."
I am returning it to you parecelpost today.
With it I am sending a book "The Pot Upon The Wheel" by
"Patience Worth". - I had thought I had another book by
Patience Worth which I wished also to give to A.R.E. Library
but it is gone, I suppose we loaned it years ago - & you know
what!
I consider Casper Yost's book about Patience Worth and Mrs.
Curran of St. Louis an excellent, objective and honest piece
of reporting spendidly organized.
My wife Eleanor, (a member of A.R.E. and, with me, a friend
of Edgar Cayce there at Virginia Beach), was a journalist.
Among many another, she went to St. Louis, interviewed Mrs.
Curran, sat with others throughout a number of ouija board
sesssions. That was about 1914 or 1915. Sorry we have no
clippings of her stories about the interviews etc. from the
newspapers she wrote for. She said that Mrs. Curran was
completely ethical, genuine; that Mrs. C. may have had
clairvoyance or other psychic powers independently but seemed
not to use them consciously, if indeed she had them. There
was no charlatanism or hanky-panky of any kind whatever about
Mrs. Curran.
Patience Worth was a psychic mystery sure enough to Casper
Yost and so she was to Mrs. Mitchell. She is much less so to
anyone who knew Edgar Cayce and know the Readings. But Mrs.
Mitchell and I had never heard of EC in those days, indeed
not until some 25 years later.
I am writing this out as perhaps you keep files on the
subject of Patience Worth & Mrs. Curran.
Sincerely [...]



Edgar Cayce Readings © 1971, 1993, 1994, 1995 by the Edgar Cayce Foundation