9/25/39 [
2017]'s father's letter to HLC:
"...In my letter of August 16th, I also asked you to send me
any information you had about thyroid gland troubles, and you
said that you didn't have any information on that disease,
and suggested an individual reading on this case. My
daughter's thyroid gland is affected and I am anxious to get
a reading. She is now under the care of a physician, but I
want to know if he is doing the right thing. If not, I can
always change the doctor. Please register me as a member,
for which I am enclosing my check for $20.00, and give an
appointment for my daughter whose name is [
2017]. [
2017]
was born in Antwerp, Belgium on April 15, 1914.
"Could you be present at the time of the reading, and
after the reading, ask your father some questions for
me? Provided, of course, that he does not answer these
questions beforehand. I can give you the doctor's diagnosis
beforehand. You can either tell your father about it or keep
it to yourself until after the reading. My main object is to
know the cause of such a disease and the method of treatment
for it. As soon as I hear from you about the day of the
appointment, I'll let you know about the doctor's diagnosis,
and the treatment he is giving, and will ask you to ask him
some questions, which I will let you know, at the reading. I
hope I will hear from you soon.
"I hope you will let me know when you come to New York, and
we can discuss this case, as well as others, personally.
Yes, I am in touch with Commander [
1949], and hope that we
will be able to accomplish some things together..."
"P.S. After second thought, I believe it will save time if
I tell you more definitely now, and let you know about the
questions I want to ask you.
"About a year ago, she [
2017] was working hard in a store
as an artist in window display work. Due to the long hours
of work, and certain emotional upsets, she lost weight and
energy. The doctor diagnosed her case to be suffering from
exophthalmic goitre. After a few month's treatment, I sent
her to California, where she regained her weight, which
is normal now. Her blood pressure is also normal, but the
thyroid gland is still troubling her. Her pulse is high and
her breathing short, and she hasn't very much energy to do
strenuous work. Her neck is somewhat swollen, showing a
fibrous type of goitre, and her eyes are slightly bulging.
The treatment, I hope, will tell us how to get rid of this
trouble.
"Please ask him if the bulging of the eyes will go back to
normal or not, and is there anything that can be done about
it. What kind of diet should she have? Is it all right for
her to exercise, or go out for a walk daily, or stay home and
rest, as her doctor has told her to do?
"Some doctors (not our doctor) insist that the only cure
for goitre is an operation or x-ray treatment, or some form
of electric treatment. As I am opposed to either of these
methods, I would like to know your father's opinion about
it..."
REPORTS
10/06/39 EC's letter to [
2017]'s father:
"Hope you have found the information for Miss [
2017] of
interest. Have through the years seen and had several
cases of this nature; had them in most every stage of
development. Very few operations have been suggested, one
here and there, and certainly hope such will not be the case
here. I do not know whether the secretary suggested any one
for you to see about the suggestions or not, but there are
two, either of whom, I would say, could and will handle the
condition, I believe. Dr. Dobbins or Dr. Robinson, each of
these gentlemen have seen a number of cases for whom readings
have been given; Dr. Dobbins possibly more than the other.
But it might be well to have the opinion of each of these
men... Will be most anxious to hear from you, also as
to what either or both doctors say..."
10/19/39 [
2017]'s father's letter to EC:
"Thank you for the reading of my daughter, [
2017], which
I received promptly; also your kind letter of October 6th,
which followed. The reading is complete and accurate and
the treatment suggested sounds very reasonable. I had told
already your son, Hugh Lynn, about the trouble [
2017] had;
not that it makes much difference to me, but I am interested
to know if you knew of the case before you went to sleep,
or you found out about it during or after the reading. You
had already answered most of my questions in the body of the
reading, and I notice that no more questions were asked while
you were asleep.
"I first consulted with my old doctor, Dr. Richard Van Rumpt,
[Richard Van Rumpt, N.D.] who is acquainted with your work.
He thought the diagnosis was correct and the treatment
suggested, good, except that he thought the Violet Ray will
do more harm than good, as it will unnecessarily stimulate
the thyroid gland. He also thought the 4th dorsal should not
be touched. What he wants to do is to break the adhesions
around the thyroid, and the abdomen, and relax and cure the
thyroid that way.
"I also saw Dr. Dobbins. He also thinks that the Violet Ray
will not do any good, although he thinks it may not do any
harm either. He is willing to examine my daughter and treat
her according to the reading.
"You suggested that I see Dr. Robinson. I do not know who
he is. I saw about eight to ten doctors by that name in the
telephone book, but I don't know which one he is. Please
give me his first name and address.
"Please also tell me if it will be all right to leave out the
Violet Ray treatment and go on with the others. [
2017] is
still in the hands of this specialist. I am planning to stop
his treatment and PROBABLY go to Dr. Dobbins. This I will
do very likely next week, after I receive your answer. I
am not going to buy the Violet Ray machine until I hear
from you..."
"P.S. Some other friends who have pretty good understandings
of diseases and health, say the same thing about the Violet
Ray that it is not to be recommended. I am naturally
interested to know about it."
10/21/39 EC's letter to [
2017]'s father:
"I have yours of the 19th. I'm glad you found the reading
in accordance with the conditions and reasonable, and I am
sure it will be helpful. No, Hugh Lynn had not spoken to
me regarding your daughter until after the reading when
questions have been answered. Mrs. Cayce doesn't usually ask
them over again, only when individuals insist they be asked.
But we desire to have the questions, that the condition may
be covered if it seems to be vague.
"As regarding the Violet Ray, use your own judgment about
same. In the greater number of cases where such conditions
have been described, the Violet Ray has been suggested.
Whether the patient got better in spite of its use or that it
was a help, I do not know. But as the doctors seem to feel
it could be detrimental, why try it without, and if you don't
find the progress desired, we will ask about same, and see
what would be suggested under the circumstances.
"Dr. Lawrence Robertson, 60 East 42nd Street, has seen a
number of cases. I gave his name not knowing which would be
the most convenient for you. Dr. Van Rumpt should be able to
handle the case if you prefer.
"As for cases of sleeping sickness, [asked about on card
of same date] while we have had several such cases, none
have ever been written up, and would require under present
arrangements, a good deal of research to give you anything
that was general or specific, as given in the readings.
We are hoping some time when we are able to have a
cross index on the cases, to be able to have all
such information available. We haven't it just now.
"Hoping Miss [
2017] will get as wonderful results as other
cases of a similar nature..."
10/30/39 Mrs. [
1602]'s letter:
"...Dr. [...] called me up and said he had had a reading
for his daughter [
2017] and that it prescribed thus and so
and Dr. Dobbins. Well, he reports he went to Dobbins and
Dobbins said the reading was okay, all but the ray treatments
which, he apparently does not believe in, so he succeeded in
boloxing Dr. [...] up to such an extent that he hasn't done
anything! (That was last week.) I am going to have him meet
Dr. Taylor [William D. Taylor, N.D.] with the idea in mind
that he will be able to instill confidence in following the
reading and generally in the work..."
11/05/39 Mrs. [
1602]'s letter:
"...Had Dr. [...] meet Dr. Taylor, also [
1749] here the other
day, and Dr. Taylor helped a great deal. He was most decided
in his opinion about following the reading as given, and
explained that the only time he had no results from the
readings, was when he thought he knew more than they did.
But that was only once. I thought he was splendid in his
confidence, which was what [...] was asking for. So, the
Violet Ray will be used (I think) and Dobbins will go on with
the rest of the work. All is well, thanks to Dr. Taylor's
help at that juncture..."
1/22/40 [
2017]'s father's letter to EC:
"In your previous reading of October 5, 1939 for my daughter,
[
2017], you stated that after six to ten weeks you wanted to
know her condition and make an appointment to 'check up' on
her condition. It is now two months and three weeks (about
eleven to twelve weeks) since the first reading, and I
wish to have a 'check up' on her condition. I didn't write
before, because I heard through Mr. [...] of Boston that you
were planning to be in New York soon and I was anxious to see
you, but I understand through Mrs. [
1602] that you may not
be here until the first week in February. Please give us an
appointment at your earliest convenience.
"Let me explain what I have done with my daughter.
"I took her to Dr. Dobbins and he has been giving her
osteopathic treatments twice a week ever since. She missed
only a few treatments. I am giving her Violet Ray treatment
every other day. She is taking Atomidine as directed, also
Watermelon Seed tea once or twice a week. She is especially
careful about her eliminations. We have, therefore, followed
the instructions given by you as closely as possible.
"Her condition, I think, has improved considerably. Dr.
Dobbins also thinks she has. Her neck and eyes are a little
better. After she stopped taking sedative drugs, her pulse
went up again, but now it is going down again. Naturally
she is happier and more optimistic. Soon I am planning to
have a metabolism [test] taken to see what improvement her
metabolism shows.
"Please give us a reading of the present condition and again
tell us what to do after this: Whether to continue the same
treatments or something else. Please tell us specifically
whether the Violet Ray treatment is of benefit, and whether
the osteopathic treatments should be given twice a week or
not.
"As time goes on, she is becoming more restless and is
anxious either to find a position downtown or to study in a
school. Please let us know if it is advisable for her to do
so.
"Please give more specific directions about her food, etc.
Some have suggested that she take a fruit fast for a few
weeks, but Dr. Dobbins does not agree with it. She tried
to do that for a week or so and her weight came down. Dr.
Dobbins does not want her weight to come down. Please let us
know more definitely about food. I do hope an operation of
the thyroid will be avoided and I am willing to do everything
for her complete cure without surgical aid.
"Awaiting for your appointment and wishing you a very happy,
peaceful and prosperous 1940..."
1/30/40 See
2017-2.



Edgar Cayce Readings © 1971, 1993, 1994, 1995 by the Edgar Cayce Foundation