6/22/28 Letter from EC to Prof. [
2711]: "Mr. [
900] of New
York asked me to have copies made of the enclosed readings
and send them to you. As I understand, he has written
you concerning the correlation of some of the information
furnished in these with conditions in the present, and with
the inclinations in the lives of several of us.
"I'm hoping you find the information given in your Life
Reading interesting, as well as the enclosed, and worth
looking into.
"I hardly know how to address you concerning the phenomena
itself, not having been a student - other than of that
presented in the information itself. I realize this is
possibly very one-sided to one who has made a thorough study
of psychic phenomena and kindred subjects as you have. The
little I know of such phenomena, however, is through personal
experience. I have read very little on the subject. I had
some correspondence with Dr. Hyslop during his lifetime,
and with Dr. Funk during his lifetime. I'm sure you know
the ideas and ideals of both of these. Just a few of
the students have I met in person. Possibly it is my own
fault (if it be a fault) that more scientific students
have not investigated the phenomena manifested through me.
Possibly it is so common and ordinary it's not even worth
investigating! but the things that have impressed me, the
things that have made me even deem it worth while, are the
results from the PHYSICAL readings that individuals have
been able to obtain for themselves through the application of
those things suggested in these readings. Then more recently
I have been much impressed with the manner, or with the life
that seems to have been developed through interest IN the
phenomena. I speak of such persons as Mr. [
900] himself.
I know he is not a SIMPLE man. I know he is unusual in his
abilities. He is, as we term here, a cold-blooded business
man; and before his personal interest in the phenomena he
apparently was wasting many of his abilities that, through
this interest in the phenomena, have developed, and have been
turned into channels that are bringing a great deal in MANY
ways into the lives of a great number of people; and, if I
am not in error, it is making those lives whom he contacts
bigger, better, more worth while; and those individuals,
at least, are feeling that they are making their lives more
worth while, and possibly the world better, from having
contacted such a man.
"So, my attitude has been - 'By their fruits ye shall know
them.'
"I don't want to fool myself, and most of all I don't want to
fool anyone else. While I do not profess to understand the
phenomena, to be sure I have a few ideas concerning same.
Whether I'm right or not possibly may be judged by that
seemingly brought into the lives of individuals through their
application, should I say, of information gained through the
readings.
"The Life Readings I understand least of all, especially that
phase that has much to say about re-incarnation. I've never
read anything, nor even heard a lecture on this subject.
Why this should have developed through this phenomena I
have been at a loss to understand. However, these are most
interesting; and, as some individual has said - they are
interesting, even if there's not a word of truth in them!
but what I'd like to know, if there is not some truth, how
do they happen to fit so well into the lives of such a great
number of people, telling them about conditions that will
arise in their lives, the inclinations, trend of thought
- and even in the lives of children who couldn't possibly
understand from their normal way of thinking, and some of
them are not even told about the circumstances, yet those
very things arise or develop in their lives. This hasn't
happened once but numbers of times. To be sure, there are
several people who are making a close study (as far as they
know how) of this phase of the phenomena, and I'm hoping -
if you find the phenomena in ANY of its phases interesting
- that we may have the privilege of having your help and
assistance, and your ideas as to the proper way TO study
it, or the various phases of it.
"I shall be very glad to hear from you if you feel inclined
to write, and shall be glad to answer any questions possible
for me to answer, that you might desire to ask. As you know,
I am the subject through which this information comes.
"I certainly hope it is going to be possible for you to
come to America and study or look over what we are trying to
do. We have started the actual erection of the building in
which the phenomena will be studied, especially the physical
side, for there will be a regular physician in charge of the
institution. We will also have a library and lecture hall,
and we are hoping we may be able to have presented, or
to purchase from England, much of the data that has been
gathered there. If you will be so kind, I am sure you can
instruct us as to just WHAT we would want in such a library.
Findings possibly of Doyle, Lodge, Lombroso, or others.
"Thanking you, I am..."
7/25/28 [
2711]'s letter to [
900]:
Dear Mr. [
900]
I expect you will have been wondering why I have not written
before now, but the fact is I have been very busy with extra
work at the University, and for several week ends my services
have been requested for giving lectures on Spiritualism
and psychic phenomena. This has required a lot of
time travelling to and fro, and I'm afraid that my
correspondence has suffered somewhat.
In the first place let me thank you very much for my own life
reading. It is correct as regards present life conditions
and the reference to my own physical conditions is accurate.
With reference to existence in previous conditions I am of
course unable to verify anything. It is however interesting
to find that I was formerly Bruce. It so happens that my
wife is a Scottish lady and belongs to Edinburgh. Possibly
inherent Scottish tendencies in myself attracted me in that
direction.
I have read with great interest the other readings and note
that the same plan runs through all viz. particulars re
conditions in earth life followed by those in previous states
of existence. It would be interesting if the controlling
entity would give some details showing more closely the
connection between present life conditions and the past. I
know it is an argument used by Theosophists that if a man
at the present time is very interested in say Egyptology
it proves that he had lived in Egypt in some previous
incarnation. Possibly this may have been the case but
many of us would like more complete information than this.
Mr. Cayce kindly forwarded me the other readings and I will
return them this week. I feel very disappointed at not being
able to come to U.S.A. this year, but hope that later on
conditions may be more favourable. I am very pleased to know
that so much good work is being done through the mediumship
of Mr. Cayce. It is a great pity that the great majority of
people do not know of some of the psychic powers which God
Almighty gave them. Here in England much psychic work is
handicapped by obsolete laws. When a psychic begins to be
very successful, it sometimes happens that some sectarians
pull the wires behind the scenes, and a legal prosecution
occurs. Things are, however, better than they were, and here
in ... one of our magistrates is a well known spiritualist.
Again thanking you for all the trouble you have taken on my
behalf, I remain,
Yours Sincerely, [
2711]
P.S. I have often wondered what is the relationship between
the exercise of our own free will and the astrological
conditions surrounding us in the past. Have any of us a
free will absolutely or is it fate?
7/30/28 Letter from [
2711]: "Many thanks for the copies of
the rdgs. which you kindly sent me some time ago. I have
gone through them carefully & find that they all follow the
same plan viz. 1st statements relating to present earth life
conditions, physical & otherwise; 2nd statements purporting
to past incarnations of the entity concerned. It is of
course for each individual to judge as regards the present
conditions of their own life; all I can say is that the
statements relating to my own physical condition are correct.
"With reference to previous states of existence, I have no
means of verifying them. However, the information should
be collected along with any other information obtained so
that, later on, it may be possible to find some definite
relationship between present & past events.
"Have you ever been given the name of the entity who
manifests through you when in the trance condition & who, I
understand, gives the readings? Also it would be interesting
to know how this entity is able to get into touch with remote
events in the life history of entities now in the earth life.
"Although I am aware that re-incarnation has been part of
Eastern philosophy for centuries, I have, so far, not come
across any clear, definite proof of it.
"I do not say it is impossible, for we have yet much to
learn concerning life & its manifestations, whether in
human beings or otherwise.
"Re the trance condition in which your rdgs. are obtained,
is the condition self-induced or have you been under
hypnotic influence by any external entity?
"It certainly seems very remarkable to an inquirer that
the controlling entity can penetrate the condition of so
many individuals who naturally possess totally different
characteristics. Can you inform me as to what proportion of
the readings are admitted to be correct, approximately. Also
if it is the SAME controlling entity every time who gives
the information. I hope the hospital which is being erected
will be a great success & that attention will be drawn to the
wonderful psychic powers inherent in man himself.
"Have you any objection to my forwarding a copy of a reading
to Sir A. Conan Doyle. I am sure he will be interested.
Also he may make some suggestions for your library, as he
keeps a psychic bookshop in London and is in touch with the
latest literature. I have many psychic books myself but
there may be a few which I have not yet seen. Wishing you
every success in the remarkably good work you are doing."
8/17/28 Mr. [
900]'s letter: "[
2711]'s communication is most
interesting. I also have a letter from him and am enclosing
it to you. Will you please return his communication in order
that I may answer same personally. I would very much like
to see the report made by you on the question [
2711] asked
in the enclosed letter regarding the relationship that
exists between the exercises of our own free will and
the astrological condition surrounding us in the past,
incorporating therein the question, - 'Have any of us free
will absolutely or is it fate?'. In taking this you would,
of course, have [
2711] before you and answer it according to
the knowledge and understanding he possesses. I should like
to see this report after you have it made and have your own
comments on same as to what it means and then with this data
answer [
2711]'s letter from my own viewpoint of that that is
given in the report correlating it with what has been given
in previous reports."
8/20/28 EC's reply to Mr. [
900]: "Dr. [
2711]'s letter is
quite interesting. I'm sure it indicates that we have access
to a source that he and his associates would like very much
to understand or know more of. Two outstanding facts, I
think, are shown us in his letter. The WHY the readings gave
Virginia, where we were able to incorporate under the laws of
the State. And, 'There will be interests from across waters
that will be unusual'. These, I think, are outstanding from
his letter to both of us. We will possibly be able to get
through Dr. [
2711] and Sir Conan Doyle a great deal of data
for our library, and I feel they will want to get as much
data from us as we are able to supply. The correlating
of the data Miss Gladys is compiling will be ESPECIALLY
interesting to them, when he gets his question answered as
you suggest we take a reading on - which we will do at the
first opportunity, though I feel it has been answered so
often before that I could give the answer without going to
sleep; though it may present it, as you say, for his OWN
mind's reaction. I'll send you the information as soon as
possible, and will write Professor [
2711] in answer to the
letter he wrote me."
8/20/28 Letter to Prof. [
2711] from EC: "I have yours of
July 30th, and I certainly appreciate your writing me as you
have. I only wish it were possible for me to talk over these
things with you in person.
"With reference to the Life Readings, our secretary Miss
Davis and my son are making a careful study of these.
Miss Davis is compiling what might be termed a HISTORY,
correlating the various facts presented in different
individuals' life readings, seeing just how they tally
with each other, and how they tally with the data that is
obtainable on the subject, time or place. This I'm sure you
would find very interesting, and I'm hoping that you will
have the opportunity to go over this with Miss Davis, and
with my son also.
"Yes, we have had times when names were given us as to who
was speaking. My impression has been, however, that Life
Readings are taken from the record made by the individual
entity itself. Possibly I get that impression more from the
manner in which I am said to act when the suggestion is given
for a Life Reading.
"No, the condition in which the readings are obtained
is self-imposed. I have had some little experience with
hypnotism, but practically all hypnotists that I have
contacted have found it impossible to hypnotize me, or to get
me beyond (when I would allow myself to be superseded) what
they termed the passive state, whatever that is.
"As to the proportion of correct information, so far, in Life
Readings - out of the hundred or more that have been made, we
have yet to have a report where the characteristics and the
mental influences were not said to be correct. As to the
controlling entity in this information, as I said before, I
BELIEVE it is the individual itself.
"The hospital is progressing very nicely. I hope to be able
to better serve humanity through its channels. I have felt,
since I was convinced there was merit in the information
obtained, that if it was right and proper some day there
would BE such an institution, and that if it wasn't right it
had no place and should not come into existence. I'm hoping,
and I believe there has been sufficient data gathered which,
if properly compiled, would convince anyone, unless it
was the most skeptic, that there IS sufficient evidence
to warrant such an institution.
"No indeed, I have no objection to your forwarding any of the
matter sent you to Sir Conan Doyle. I'd like very much to
have his personal criticism of same; for, as I have said
before, I don't want to fool myself nor anyone else, and
I know those who have studied the phenomena in any of its
phases are better able to judge it than I myself. I DO know
what it has done for myself and my own immediate family, and
many of my friends, and I can only take what others say as to
what the information has meant to them.
"Yes, I certainly hope we will be able to get some help from
Sir Doyle and yourself respecting the books or manuscripts in
the library. We hope to make the institution an educational
center, as well as a place where information given through
psychic forces may be LITERALLY carried out.
"Thanking you for your letter, and hoping you will let me
hear from you again, assuring you of my desire to be of
service if I may to your self or any of your associates,
I am..."
3/06/30 Dr. [
2711] obtained a Physical Reading. See
2711-2.



Edgar Cayce Readings © 1971, 1993, 1994, 1995 by the Edgar Cayce Foundation