12/18/80 GD's note to Charles Thomas Cayce in re setting
straight at least one of the so-called "mistakes" of Edgar
Cayce criticized in The Fate Book Review of Lytle Robinson's
IS IT TRUE WHAT THEY SAY ABOUT EDGAR CAYCE (which was taken
from Noel Langley's EDGAR CAYCE ON REINCARNATION, although I
could find no mention of this case in Lytle Robinson's
book):
In re Lytle W. Robinson's new book IS IT TRUE WHAT THEY SAY
ABOUT EDGAR CAYCE, I suggest that W. H. [Howard] Church
review the book in the Journal introducing Lytle Robinson as
an individual who had a Life Reading from Edgar Cayce (See
3/01/53 Searchlight, IMPACT OF A LIFE READING, reprinted also
in 3/69 A.R.E. Journal, taking a mature viewpoint on his
reading). Also in the Journal review Howard could clear up
the confusion about Richelieu and Sir William Harvey being
contemporaries. (See 2892-2 incarnation used in Langley's
book on REINCARNATION, made much of in the recent FATE review
of Lytle's book.) I have added a bracketed note on the
margin of 2892-2 [at the time it was brought to my attention
when the Langley book came out] indicating that Sir William
Harvey DID live during the time of Cardinal Richelieu
[1585-1642], but the first incarnation preceding the present
one was as Count Dubourse [Dubois?] in France during the time
of Richelieu, the marshal of France [1696-1788, during Louis
XV-XVI?]. Noel Langley in his book EDGAR CAYCE ON
REINCARNATION made the mistake of saying Cardinal Richelieu,
though the reading did not say which Richelieu, only saying
it was at the time "when there were disputations with the
Louises, Richelieu, and those activities in the church, as
well as the state". [Noel Langley paraphrased all of this,
not quoting the reading which if done might have prevented
all the hullabaloo.]
It is not clear whether [
2892]'s incarnation was at the time
of the above Richelieu or his grandson Duc de Richelieu
[1766-1822]. I have bracketed my note for the [1696-1788]
marshal of France Richelieu because in the answers to
[
2892]'s questions as to past associations with his family
that period seems to be pinpointed. Maybe Howard Church can
figure it out.
PS: In the review of Lytle's last book for the Journal I
think all his past books on "the work" should be listed,
pointing up especially the one article which I think has
done the most good for us - the August 1965 issue of THE
COMMONWEALTH, published by State Chamber of Commerce,
Richmond, VA., "EDGAR CAYCE - Astonishing psychic of
Virginia Beach", five pages with pictures [reprinted 1/66
in The A.R.E. Journal].