5/08/83 Stephen Goranson's letter:
Cayce and Research on a Recommended Education Book
To: Charles Thomas, Gladys, Library, Youth Activities
Department
From: Stephen Goranson, 2317 Burton Dr., VB 23454
When I read that a book Cayce recommended on education (in
#5747-1, Par. 7-A) had been located, I checked out the book
and reread the reading. While THE EDUCATION OF KARL WITTE,
or THE TRAINING OF A CHILD is an interesting story, and it
does show something of the remarkable capacity of this child
to learn, I had to conclude it was not the book Cayce
recommended because the title, author and content are all
not what Cayce said. He said "Training of Children as by
McDowell" and that Dewitt wrote another book. Yes, sometimes
things are incorrect in the readings (e.g. some of the dates)
and sometimes the transcription contains errors (e.g.
spelling and punctuation, as might be expected with Cayce's
occasionally unfamiliar language), but this kind of reversal
is not, to my knowledge, a typical error.
So I looked for another book and found it: by Margaret
McDowall, SIMPLE BEGINNINGS IN THE TRAINING OF MENTALLY
DEFECTIVE CHILDREN, London, 1921 (2nd edition). Cayce
shortened the title to ...TRAINING OF...CHILDREN. A copy
is here on loan from Ohio State University, and I will ask
the library to xerox it.
While the Witte book shows a father who has decided to
create a classics scholar out of his son (and in this case
succeeded) - an idea quite foreign to Cayce - Margaret
MacDowall's teaching is harmonious with Cayce. In the same
reading answer, Cayce says, "First of all in teaching, do
not attempt to teach one that abhors such conditions as a
clean body with one that desires to be in mud continually,
whether mind or body!" Margaret MacDowall begins her
discussion on cleaniness on page 22. Cayce said, in the
same answer, "The better is to train self first as a teacher,
in consecration of self's life to the service of the Great
Teacher, and using those same laws..." This is precisely
what Margaret MacDowall writes. Two of her key quotations:
"Himself took our infirmities and bare our sicknesses" and
"The letter killeth, but the Spirit giveth Life". Also of
interest are her dialogs with children and her references to
"Madame Montessori".
I would be interested in hearing whether you think this is
what Cayce advised.
Please allow me to comment more generally on Cayce research.
Membership surveys gathering statistics on subjective
opinions may provide an occasion for helpful experiences for
some members, but as a research method are quite limited. I
believe A.R.E. could do with less of that and less emphasis
on market research.
Compared to the potential in the readings, very little true
research is sponsored by A.R.E., apparently. Of course there
are exceptions: Gladys' preserving the readings, the library
making them available, Mark Lehner's work in Egypt, etc.,
etc. Let me take an example. Reading
907-1 claims Multiple
Sclerosis is caused by a hormone imbalance and a failure to
assimilate gold, and not by a virus. Half of the millions of
dollars in MS research is spent looking for the virus; IF
Cayce is right, it could help immensely, but only if it were
presented with research to back up the claim. But has any
A.R.E., E.C.F. or Clinic sponsored doctor read the article on
the immunology of Gold that just came out (in Prog. Med.
Chem. 82, pages 1-58)? I would guess not. Or is any such
doctor really current in the monthly progress of observed
effects of MS on thymic hormones, or aware that J-M Charcot,
who described MS over a century ago, tried to use Gold
Chloride to treat it, or compared the advances in treating
another autoimmune disease, rheumatoid arthritis, with a new
gold compound (Auranofin), which apparently causes less
negative side-effects than the previous gold treatment? This
is an example of the kind of research, in my opinion,
A.R.E./E.C.F. has as an opportunity and responsibility. I
welcome a response to this, and I regard it a positive thing
that A.R.E./E.C.F. is set up and able to do this, if it
chooses.
[signed] Stephen G.